Jeremy Pound, BBC Music Magazine
March 2023
“Opinionated but never obnoxious, accessible but never banal, as a collection they make an excellent introduction to Oxbridge and cathedral choirs in general—plus the skills needed to run a crack choral outfit. Her affection for her university, college and choirs is infectious.”
Andrew Palmer, Yorkshire Times
11 February 2023
“This book will be enjoyed not just by lovers of the English choral tradition, organs, or by those fascinated by Oxbridge colleges, but also by those with interests in education, composing, performing, publishing, politics, and religion.
Her dedication and personality jump off the page as she sets about demystifying the world she inhabits.”
Rollin Smith, The American Organist
February 2023
“Followers of Sarah MacDonald’s monthly UK Report in The American Organist will delight in her new book… Articles are arranged under subjects…along with seven selections by guest columnists. In all a wonderful collection of essays and articles on almost all the facets of the life a church organist and choral conductor.”
Alan Lewis, Anglican Association of Musicians
may - june 2023
“It would be the perfect gift for anyone who loves ‘the Anglican tradition’ but isn’t necessarily a professional or even an avocational organist.”
John Henderson, church Music Quarterly
march 2023
“It is good to have so much common sense and her many down-to-earth personal views all in one place. ”
Patrick carter, organ canada
february 2024
“Composed with an acute appreciation for what readers really want to know, these columns reflect MacDonald’s gift for sharing practical wisdom with a wry sense of humour.”
Ian Loeppky, Choral Journal
february 2024
“The writing, besides being meticulously researched, is thoroughly entertaining, engaging, and heart-felt.”
David Flood, Church Times
23 APRIL 2023
“Particularly notable are confident assertions such as ‘never treat children as if they were children’ and ‘life is too short to sing rubbish music.”